Which Dishwasher Detergent Should I Use?

Choosing the right dishwasher detergent is essential for achieving spotless dishes and maintaining your appliance’s efficiency. With multiple types available – liquid gels, powders, and pods or tablets – not to mention brands, it’s important to understand the benefits and drawbacks of each to make an informed decision. 

Types of Detergents

Liquid and Gel Detergents

Liquid and gel detergents are popular due to their ease of use and ability to dissolve quickly, making them suitable for shorter or cooler wash cycles. They are particularly effective in soft water conditions and are gentle on dishes. However, they may struggle with removing tough, baked-on residues and can sometimes leave a filmy residue if overused. Proper storage in a cool, dry place is essential to maintain their effectiveness.​

Powdered Detergents:

Powdered detergents are known for their cost-effectiveness and strong cleaning capabilities, especially on stubborn stains and heavily soiled items. Users can adjust the amount used per load, offering flexibility and potential savings. However, they require careful storage to prevent clumping and may not dissolve as readily in cooler cycles, potentially leaving residue on dishes.​ Maytag Appliances

Pods and Tablets

Pods and tablets offer pre-measured doses of detergent, ensuring consistency and convenience. Many formulations include additional agents like rinse aids and degreasers, enhancing their cleaning power. They are particularly effective in tackling tough food residues and minimizing water spots. However, they are typically more expensive per load compared to liquids or powders and require dry storage to prevent them from clumping or dissolving prematurely.​Maytag Appliances+1Consumer Reports+1Consumer Reports+1Allrecipes+1

Expert Advice

Unfortunately, since not all dishwasher work the exact same way, there are some instances where a particular detergent – even a highly rated one – may not be suitable. Our technicians repeatedly see Cascade with Dawn (sold as a gel, powder, or pod) causing too much sudsing. The suds can accumulate and leak out of the dishwasher even when everything is functioning properly. If you’re using this detergent and have noticed frequent or occasional puddles of water on the floor after completing a cycle, we suggest trying a different detergent before calling us for a dishwasher repair.

Environmental and Health Considerations

For those concerned about environmental impact and health, we’re right there with you! The Environmental Working Group (EWG) provides ratings for dishwasher detergents based on their ingredients and safety profiles. Products like AspenClean Dishwasher Pods and Blueland Dishwasher Detergent have received favorable ratings for their eco-friendly formulations. Though you may not experience the same cleaning results with these products, the tradeoff may be worthwhile for the environment and your peace of mind.  

Conclusion

Selecting the best dishwasher detergent depends on your specific needs, preferences, and local water conditions. Pods and tablets offer convenience and powerful cleaning but at a higher cost per load. Liquids and gels provide flexibility and are gentle on dishes but may require careful dosing to avoid residue. Powdered detergents are cost-effective and get rid of tough stains, but necessitate proper storage to maintain their efficacy. Considering expert reviews and environmental impact can further guide your choice to ensure both sparkling dishes and a sustainable home. Have a Maytag dishwasher and want to know what they say? Check out this helpful article on their website for choosing a detergent specifically for your Maytag dishwasher.Looking for more dishwasher tips and maintenance advice? Check out our blog post answering the question, Suds in your Dishwasher?. If your dishwasher is leaking, not cleaning dishes well, or leaving them soaking wet when it used to leave them dry, and you’ve already tried switching detergents, call Appliance Professional or schedule a service online today. We’re here to help!